Why a Gradeless Classroom Transforms Learning
Moving Beyond ‘What Did I Get?’ to ‘What Do I Know?
Early in my teaching career, I encountered standards-based and proficiency grading systems that used rubrics alongside a minimum failing grade of 50%. When I saw a side-by-side comparison of the traditional A-F grading scale next to an equally weighted proficiency scale, the choice became clear: grading should reflect true learning, not just a percentage.
This approach gave my students a chance to recover from a “bad” grade, but more importantly, it shifted the conversation beyond “What did I get?” to “What can I show I know?” It helped me, and my students, focus on whether they were truly learning the material I was teaching.
Photo by Eugene Zhyvchik on Unsplash
Over the past 20+ years in the classroom, I’ve held fast to this belief. An A is an A. An F is an F. But the percentages don’t drive my grading practices proficiency does. Education has been evolving toward proficiency language for decades, and it’s time we embrace what it really means for student learning.
Photo by Anne Nygård on Unsplash
Understanding Proficiency Levels
If you’ve heard terms like emergent or novice, these describe students who are well below proficiency expectations. For me, this often means the student needs more exposure to the content or additional support to grasp the concept. It could also mean no evidence of learning if the student hasn’t completed the work. Traditionally, this would be an F on the report card.
The next level, approaching, means the student is getting closer but still has misconceptions or gaps holding them back. These students benefit from real-world connections, peer collaboration, or revisiting the material in new ways. In traditional grading, this might be a D.
At proficiency, students meet the standard—they understand the concepts and can apply their learning in related situations. This is the baseline of mastery, often equivalent to a C grade. These students feel confident but might not yet be ready to teach others.
Finally, students who exceed expectations demonstrate mastery or go beyond proficiency. They show deep understanding and can explain or teach the material to peers, earning A’s or B’s in traditional terms.
Photo by Brad Starkey on Unsplash
Changing the Conversation
By shifting to proficiency-focused grading, I’ve changed how I talk to students about their work. Instead of students asking, “What did I get right or wrong?” the question becomes, “What can I demonstrate that I know?”
When I introduced this to my seventh graders last November, they were uncomfortable at first. They were used to receiving clear right-or-wrong feedback and hadn’t been asked to revise or defend their work. This discomfort made me realize I needed to build their confidence and accountability in owning their learning.
That’s when I connected with colleagues and educators like Starr Sackstein. Our conversations inspired me to explore “learning progressions” a tool that makes expectations transparent and guides students through their growth.
What’s Next?
Proficiency-based grading isn’t just about changing how we assign grades—it’s about empowering students to become active participants in their learning journey. When students understand what mastery looks like, they can take ownership, set goals, and strive for deeper understanding.
I believe learning should never be a secret kept from students. By making learning visible and meaningful, we prepare our kids not just to pass tests but to thrive in school and beyond.
Photo by Christian Agbede on Unsplash
Join the Conversation
Have you tried proficiency-based grading or experienced a gradeless classroom? How has it changed your view of learning? I’d love to hear your stories and questions—please share them in the comments below!
If you’re passionate about transforming education, to Led by Learners for more insights, stories, and practical tips to empower teachers, students, and families.